Smallwood to join Lauer, Naab on Hamilton City Council

Voters cast their ballots during early voting at Butler County Board of Elections Tuesday, Oct. 21 in Hamilton. NICK GRAHAM/STAFF

Credit: Nick Graham

Credit: Nick Graham

Voters cast their ballots during early voting at Butler County Board of Elections Tuesday, Oct. 21 in Hamilton. NICK GRAHAM/STAFF

Councilman Joel Lauer said his next term starts now as he earned another one on Hamilton City Council, according to unofficial election results Tuesday night.

Lauer finished in the second position with 23.47% in the five-person race, with the top three vote-getters earning a seat on City Council. Unofficial results show Lauren Copas Smallwood earned the top spot with 23.49% of votes, which equates to about two votes more than Lauer received.

Provisional ballots cast on Election Day and vote-by-mail ballots received by Friday will be counted on Nov. 25 during the official run of the election.

These votes will determine Hamilton’s next vice mayor, a two-year position awarded to the top vote-getter in every odd-year election year. There are a few dozen provisional ballots still to be counted during the official run of the election later this month.

Five people were seeking three open seats on Hamilton City Council in the Nov. 4, 2025, general election. On Tuesday, Lauren Copas Smallwood was elected to Hamilton City Council, earning one of the three seats up for election. Pictured is Smallwood listening to a question being asked during a Sept. 24, 2025, candidates' forum hosted by the Greater Chamber of Commerce at Miami Downtown Hamilton Center on High Street. MICHAEL D. PITMAN/STAFF

Credit: Michael D. Pitman

icon to expand image

Credit: Michael D. Pitman

Regardless of the final vote-count, Lauer and Smallwood both said the work on the next four years starts now.

“My slogan was constant improvement, not constant change,” said Lauer, a Garfield middle school teacher. “I want to continue on making those improvements and continuing on the path of economic development, revitalizing our neighborhoods and our community.”

Smallwood said she has a growing list of ideas and topics she wants to address with her soon-to-be fellow councilmembers, and one of the first is how to improve communication with citizens.

“I want there to be open communication, I want Hamiltonians to know about the decision-making processes early and not after the fact,” she said. “I think anybody that has worked with me in any capacity, be it professional or through civic engagement knows that I like to get things done. I like to keep things moving. I like to be purposeful and intentional.”

Hamilton City Councilman Joel Lauer reacts to a comment during a debate at the Hamilton Rotary Club on  Oct. 9, 2025. On Tuesday, Nov. 4, 2025, Lauer was re-elected to Hamilton City Council, earning one of the three seats that were up for election. MICHAEL D. PITMAN/STAFF

Credit: Michael D. Pitman

icon to expand image

Credit: Michael D. Pitman

Councilman Tim Naab, who could not be reached on election night, earned the third spot and his fifth consecutive term. He earned 21.3% of the vote.

Naab, an Army combat veteran, previously told the Journal-News he wants to see some projects to fruition, including helping to bring online the planned hotels at 20 High St. and the corner of High Street and North MLK Boulevard, and seeing construction begin on the Crawford Hoying mixed-use development.

Candidates Pat Bach and Andrew Conn finished fourth (19.2%) and fifth (12.5%), respectively.

Councilman Michael Ryan, a two-time vice mayor, did not run for reelection to the council and is instead focusing on challenging Butler County Commissioner Cindy Carpenter in the 2026 Republican primary.

This was Conn’s second time seeking a council seat and the first time for Smallwood and Bach.

Hamilton City Councilman Tim Naab reacts to an comment during a debate at the Hamilton Rotary Club on  Oct. 9, 2025. On Tuesday, Nov. 4, 2025, Naab was re-elected to Hamilton City Council, earning one of the three seats to be filled. MICHAEL D. PITMAN/STAFF

Credit: Michael D. Pitman

icon to expand image

Credit: Michael D. Pitman

About the Author